G'day,
I'll start with the negatives:
* The number one let-down with the Hilux 4x2 Hi-Rider is it's a pegga. This embarrassed me at FarmWorld last year when it pegged its was across the hill slope & I was forced to park with the other 2WDs, and once I nearly got bogged in a slushy grass carpark at a winter footy ground. Those are the only two times though where I've needed a lockable (or limited slip) diff.
* The 60L needle range is annoying considering it's an 80L tank, I've taken it to maybe 100kms beyond "empty" & it took 67L.
* The DPF clean, when it activates, shits me, but only because I reset the fuel consumption with every tank & watch the fuel consumption rolling graph as I'm driving. You see the consumption go down, down, down then all of a sudden the DPF clean starts, it spikes & plateaus for 5-40 minutes & you just watch the average consumption go up, up, up, before DPF stops and the average gradually drops again. I think it does a DPF clean roughly once every 500kms.
* I'm still convinced the SR's suspension is a bit harsher than the father-in-law's 2013 SR5, and outside of town probably a tad harsher than a Ranger XLT.
* The touch-screen's Toyota navigation stuff is a bit shit, but I only have an SR & they have something that's halfway between static maps & proper navigation. I also have an older iphone which isn't the best for pairing with vehicle bluetooth/USB in general. If the touch screen could hook up to Google or Apple it would be A+. The touch screen in general is pretty good, excellent sound quality & easy to use.
Pros:
* They get the same suspension as the 4x4
* Can tow like a champ
* It bashes through the paddocks/undergrowth at home with no dramas.
* I have not had a single mechanical or electrical problem with the Hilux.
* Highway average drops to low 7's (before the DPF kicks in), long-term all-round average is 8.2L/100km.
I haven't had a chance to take it camping yet. The tub (behind the wheel arches) is large enough for a double swag but I'd need to make up a half-stand with legs for the rest of the double swag to sit over the tailgate.
I've towed trailerloads of soil, gravel, rubbish, and have chucked bins, firewood & furniture in the tub. The only way you can tell you're towing something is when you hit the brakes.
I have driven it on some fairly rough tracks. Clearance is the same as a 4WD, its biggest issue would be getting bogged the same way a pegga car can get bogged. If funds allow, then in the future I may spend some coin on an e-locker diff.
The dogs love the tub, I tie them to the headboard and they sit on a Bunnings rubber ute mat I cut to shape. The SR5 bar helps with the dogs, but hinders if you wish to load stuff in the tub.
I've recently topped 30,000kms. 95% of the time is to/from work, but I've driven it in Melbourne traffic & it's good on long roadtrips for comfort. It has cupholders everywhere & a chiller compartment above the glovebox.
I am the only person I know of who has a 4x2 Hi-Rider, so that tells me that if I needed to sell it I might be in for a hard time. Having said that I've seen quite a few Ranger XL/XLT Hi-Riders around, and a mate has an XL Hi-Rider workhorse with a diff lock (air locker?). In direct comparison against an XL the SR is far comfier/better-appointed, but as a workhorse I think the Ranger's diff lock is a better thing to have. His 2.2 is a slug, my 2.8 shits all over it.
I hope that answers all your questions, feel free to hit me up with more questions if you have any

Cheers
Dave